
By Chris Armstrong, reprinted from Humanism as a Way of Life.
Third of a series.
This view of God as the cosmic killjoy comes out even more clearly in Lewis’s other, lesser known memoir: the allegorical Pilgrim’s Regress, which was the first book he wrote after his conversion.
In this book, Lewis has his protagonist, John, grow up in a place called “Puritania,” where religion was both negative and oppressive. As a child, John was severely disciplined for boyish activities such as picking primroses and taking aim with his slingshot at a bird, and was told that if he did such things, he would anger “The Steward” – a sanctimonious clergyman character, as well as the fearsome “Landlord” – who is the distant, wrathful Christian God.
When John finally met the Steward, he was given a card containing, as the Steward said, “all the things the Landlord says you must not do.” Lewis has John observe,
“Half the rules seem to forbid things he had never heard of, and the other half forbade things he was doing every day and could not imagine not doing; and the number of the rules was so enormous that he felt he could never remember them all.”
Lewis’s later writings in popular theology often portrayed a more positive spirituality, in which heavenly flourishing was not so destructive to the earthly variety.
So having suggested that there are some reasons we can still learn from Lewis about flourishing, established that he had much to say on the subject, and reviewed a couple of examples of his thought on flourishing, let’s round out the picture a bit.
I’ll start by borrowing a word ethicist Gilbert Meilaender has used for Lewis’s thought: “dialectical.” The word may not be familiar to you – it simply means “exploring truth by analyzing opposing ideas or contradictions”—some people describe this as finding a “thesis” and then its opposite “antithesis,” and then reconciling them into a synthesis—a well-rounded conclusion that somehow holds two opposites together.
Bearing that in mind, let’s look at what Lewis said, one day in 1947, when he was invited to talk to a group of nuns who ran Our Lady of Lourdes hospital in Drogheda, Ireland.
In that talk, Lewis painted a picture of someone encountering Christianity for the first time. This person, he said to the sisters, might see Christianity’s asceticism, its celebrations of martyrdom, its meditations on mortality, and its instruction to store up treasure not on earth but in heaven . . . and conclude that this is essentially a world-denying religion.
On the other hand, this person might also look to the long history of Christendom and see that almost every institution and social good – in architecture, law, healthcare, poor relief, higher education, the arts – these were built by Christian people out of Christian conviction. And they could conclude that this is a world-affirming religion.
In fact, Lewis noted, our historic faith holds these two sides together: the world-denying and the world-affirming sides. “Only Christianity,” he said, “leaves you free both to enjoy your breakfast and to mortify your inordinate appetites.”
Lewis ended that talk with a wonderful short statement that I used to put at the bottom of all my email sign-offs: “Because we love something else more than this world, we love even this world better than those who know no other.” Isn’t that good? “Because we love something else more than this world, we love even this world better than those who know no other.”
Like much of what Lewis said about Christianity, this is a piece of wisdom that wouldn’t have surprised most people in the old Christian West – but that may strike us now as fresh and intriguing. Though we moderns tend to spiritualize our faith, breaking off the “world-affirming” side of the dialectic in favor of the “world-denying” side, Lewis will have none of it.
Lewis went on to argue that despite the real world-denying aspects of our faith, we are without doubt better equipped than secular materialists to help our neighbors flourish—in this life as well as beyond.
In a talk on “the good life” for a student audience, Lewis reminded his readers that “Christianity claims to give a true account of facts – to tell you what the real universe is like.”
And if that account is true (he said), then
“it is quite impossible that those who know this truth and those who don’t should be equally well equipped for leading a good life. While a Christian and a non-Christian may both wish to do good to their fellow men, the one believes that men are going to live forever, that they were created by God and so built that they can find their true and lasting happiness only by being united to God, that they have gone badly off the rails, and that obedient faith in Christ is the only way back. . . .”
“The other believes that men are an accidental result of the blind workings of matter, that they started as mere animals and have more or less steadily improved, that they are going to live for about seventy years, that their happiness is fully attainable by good social services and political organizations, and that everything else . . . is to be judged to be “good” or “bad” simply in so far as it helps or hinders that kind of ‘happiness.’”
In short, Lewis concluded,
“The Christian and the Materialist hold different beliefs about the universe. They can’t both be right. The one who is wrong will act in a way which simply doesn’t fit the real universe. Consequently, with the best will in the world, he will be helping his fellow creatures to their destruction.”
I find it fascinating that in pushing back against the modern scientific materialist reduction of human flourishing to merely material and social goods, Lewis offers a Christian description of flourishing that still strongly affirms the material and social dimensions of flourishing. Though he spoke harshly about utopian technocratic solutions to human misery, he was able to affirm our ordinary, material and social lives as good. That is why Meilaender’s term “dialectic” seems an apt tag for Lewis on flourishing.
Drawing from the resources of Christian tradition, he consistently argued that if we want to love our neighbors by helping them to flourish, on the one hand, we cannot for a moment slip into the secularist view that we are just biological beings. But we also cannot, on the other hand, go around treating people like “souls on sticks”—ignoring the clues in our desiring natures that tell us that God wants us to flourish, too, in our bodies and in our relationships.