Being Black in the Movement: Why Is Work Hard?

Harry Mitchell

Part two of a series.

Christians need a theology that can distinguish between work that is difficult because human life is fallen and work that has been made unjust through human decisions, institutional practices, and systems of power. The Faith and Work conversation does not always make that distinction clearly enough. When every harmful workplace experience is placed under the broad category of broken work, preventable injustice can begin to look like an unavoidable condition that faithful workers must simply endure.

The Faith and Work Movement has rightly emphasized that work is part of God’s good creation. Human beings were given work before sin entered the biblical story; work itself is therefore not a curse. Genesis 3 teaches, however, that sin profoundly altered the experience of work. The ground would produce thorns and thistles, and human labor would involve struggle, frustration, and toil. Work would remain good, but it would no longer function entirely as God intended. This creation, Fall, and redemption framework has helped many Christians understand why meaningful work can also be difficult. Yet we need to apply it more carefully. Yes, work can be difficult because we live in a fallen world. Work can also be made unjust through human choices, organizational practices, cultural assumptions, and systems of power. The category of difficult or broken work does not adequately explain everything workers experience.

Every worker encounters difficulty. A demanding assignment, difficult customer, disappointing evaluation, failed project, conflict with a coworker, or stressful season does not automatically indicate injustice. Work requires effort, discipline, patience, learning, and perseverance. Work becomes unjust when people are denied dignity, fair treatment, appropriate compensation, protection, or opportunity. It becomes unjust when power is used to exploit, exclude, silence, or disadvantage workers. Injustice can appear in individual actions, but it can also become embedded in policies, routines, professional standards, informal networks, and institutional cultures.

The distinction matters because the Christian response to ordinary difficulty may not be the appropriate response to injustice. If every workplace problem is reduced to personal attitude or a challenge to one’s obedience or faithfulness, Christians may encourage workers to endure unfair conditions that should actually be confronted. A worker experiencing discrimination may be told to pray more, work harder, forgive, remain positive, or demonstrate greater excellence. Those responses may contain spiritual value, but they do not address the injustice itself. They can unintentionally place the entire burden upon the person being harmed.

I experienced this during my years in corporate management. At different points in my career, I worked at levels where I had no Black peers. I knew the loneliness of entering meetings, leadership gatherings, and employee-recognition events where no one else looked like me or shared the same journey. I once traveled out of state with other members of our company’s regional (executive) leadership team. When we arrived at the customer’s office, I was told that, per the customer, I could not attend the meeting because I was Black, and I did not attend. At another point, while working in the South, I discovered that bringing a white subordinate with me made it easier to secure appointments with white male customers who would not respond to me in the same way. I also experienced an employee challenging my managerial authority under circumstances in which the racial dimensions were known but not adequately addressed.

These were not merely difficult days at work. They were not thorns and thistles in a general sense that affected every worker equally. They were experiences shaped by racial perceptions, relationships, and institutional responses. The theology of work helped me approach corporate management as ministry. It taught me to lead faithfully, exercise stewardship, serve people, and understand my work as accountable to God. But I also needed a theology that could help me understand what it meant to carry out that ministry while my authority, competence, or belonging could be questioned because I was Black.

This does not mean that every disappointing outcome is discriminatory, nor does it eliminate a worker’s responsibility to grow, learn, and perform well. It means that performance occurs within systems of interpretation. People evaluate work, and they do not enter those evaluations without assumptions. A theology that teaches excellence without examining how excellence is recognized can leave workers unprepared for unequal outcomes. It may even cause them to blame themselves for every barrier they encounter. The question cannot be only, “Did the worker perform faithfully?” We must also ask, “Was the worker treated justly?”

The Bible does not treat workplace justice as peripheral to faithful work. Deuteronomy commands, “You shall not oppress a hired worker who is poor and needy,” whether that worker is a fellow Israelite or a foreigner living in the land (Deuteronomy 24:14). James condemns those who withhold wages from laborers and declares that the cries of the workers have reached the Lord (James 5:4). Paul instructs those with workplace authority to treat those under them “justly and fairly,” remembering that they, too, are accountable to a Master in heaven (Colossians 4:1). These passages move beyond the character and performance of individual workers. They address the conduct of employers, owners, supervisors, and others who possess power. They recognize that relationships and systems govern work through which resources, protection, opportunity, and authority are distributed.

A biblical theology of work must therefore address both sides of the working relationship. It should teach employees how to work faithfully, but it should also teach leaders how to create fair conditions. It should form honest workers and accountable employers. It should encourage personal perseverance while confronting institutional practices that make perseverance unnecessarily difficult for certain people. Justice is not an optional addition to the theology of work. It is part of what faithful work requires.

When Pharaoh oppressed the Israelites, God did not merely teach them to find purpose in forced labor. God heard their cries, confronted the power oppressing them, and acted to liberate them. The biblical response included comfort for the oppressed, but it also included judgment upon oppression. A Christian theology of work should likewise care for the person who has been harmed and ask what must change in the workplace. Otherwise, theology can become a means of helping people adjust to injustice instead of equipping the church to confront it.

The question is not only, “How can this worker remain faithful?” It is also, “What does faithfulness require of those with the power to change these conditions?” Christian managers, executives, business owners, human-resource leaders, board members, investors, and influential professionals are not merely called to express personal faith through individual behavior. They steward systems that shape the working lives of other people. A Christian leader can act kindly toward individual employees while presiding over practices that consistently produce unfair and unequal outcomes. Personal kindness is important, but it is not a substitute for institutional justice. Faithful leadership requires leaders to examine both their intentions and the effects of the systems they oversee.

The traditional theology of work does not need to abandon its teaching about the Fall. It needs a more complete account of how the Fall affects work. Sin is personal, but it does not remain private. Human decisions become policies. Repeated practices become organizational culture. Cultural assumptions influence standards. Standards distribute opportunity. Over time, unequal outcomes can become normalized even when no single person intends them. This is how sin becomes embedded in systems.

A theology that speaks only about personal sin may recognize the biased supervisor but fail to recognize the hiring process that repeatedly disadvantages certain applicants. It may condemn an openly racist statement while overlooking informal networks that continually direct opportunities toward the same group. It may encourage interpersonal reconciliation without examining the institutional conditions that made the injury possible. A fuller theology of the Fall should help Christians recognize sin in individuals, relationships, institutions, cultures, and systems. A fuller theology of redemption should ask what repairing each level requires. The redemption of work cannot mean only helping individual Christians discover meaning in the work that already exists. It must also include repairing relationships, practices, and institutions that prevent work from reflecting God’s intentions for human dignity, service, justice, and flourishing. Work is difficult in a fallen world, but not every burden should be accepted as inevitable. Some thorns grow from the condition of the ground. Others have been planted, cultivated, and protected by human beings. A faithful theology of work must help us recognize the difference.

Post navigation

  One thought on “Being Black in the Movement: Why Is Work Hard?”

  1. William Messenger's avatar
    William Messenger
    November 17, 2026 at 11:58 am

    Fantastic post. Our movement is indeed in danger of encouraging people to submit to systems of injustice and abuse at work, and of failing to encourage those with the power to change such systems. Not intentionally (usually) but by not paying attention to the distinction between inherent hardships, individual failings, and intentional systems that perpetuate unfair treatment.

    I was fortunate early in my career to witness someone stand up to this in small but significant way. I was a systems engineer in a sales office of IBM. One day I was meeting with the branch manager in charge of our office. Her phone rang, and she said it was a call from the branch’s biggest customer, and she was going to take it. I asked if she wanted me to leave the “No,” she said, “i’m going to put it on speaker. Stay and listen silently, I want you to hear this.”

    The customer demanded that she replace the new account manager that she had assigned them a few weeks previously. The branch manager (and I) knew that the account manager was one of the most capable people in the branch. She asked why the customer wanted her to remove him. The customer said the account manager was a bad cultural fit, didn’t gel with the customer’s information technology team, didn’t have the confidence of the department, etc. He made it clear that he didn’t want a black person in the role, without ever saying so directly. He hinted that if she didn’t make the change, he would take his business elsewhere than IBM. In practical terms, this would mean buying used IBM equipment from second-hand dealers, rather than new equipment from IBM, which could be a major loss of revenue to our branch and could cause the branch manager to receive poor performance appraisal and career setback.

    The branch manager said, “I understand very clearly what you’re asking, and my decision is no. If you consider that a reason to stop doing business with IBM, that decision is up to you. Please do not make this kind of request again.”

    She hung up, then said to me, “IBM has a responsibility not only to treat all our people equally within the company, but also to stand up for what’s right with customers and others we deal with. We are a powerful corporation, and we have to use that power justly. If we don’t, who will?” Not everyone at IBM would have done what she did, but she was willing to use the power she had for good.

    I wonder how well I’ve lived up to the example she set for me.

    Like

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.